Guides

Obsolete PLC: when to replace it

A PLC can run for twenty years without failing. The problem comes the day it fails and there is no spare, no program and nobody who knows it.

Augusto Martini Chacon · Domotica Valencia · Updated:

In short

A PLC is obsolete when the manufacturer stops making and supporting it. It keeps working, but a failure can stop the machine for weeks. Plan the replacement when new spares are no longer available, there is no copy of the program or the unit cannot communicate with current systems. The first step is always to save a copy of the program.

How do you know whether a PLC is obsolete?

Manufacturers publish the status of each product family. It usually goes through these phases:

Life-cycle phases of a PLC
PhaseWhat it meansWhat to do
ActiveManufactured and sold as normalNothing special: keep copies of the program
Mature or phase-outAn end-of-sale date is announcedBuy critical spares and plan the migration
DiscontinuedNo longer made; only repair or second-handMigrate at the next planned stop
UnsupportedNo spares and no official repairHigh risk: any failure means a long stop

What signs show it is unwise to wait?

  • There is no copy of the program, or nobody knows whether the copy is the latest version.
  • The program can only be opened with an old computer or a cable that is no longer sold.
  • Spares are only available second-hand.
  • The memory backup battery has never been changed.
  • The person who knew the machine has left the company.
  • Production data is needed and the unit has no communications.

What migration options are there?

The brand of the new PLC is best chosen according to what the plant already has: a single family of equipment simplifies spares and maintenance training.

Ways of migrating an obsolete PLC
OptionWhat it involvesAdvantageDrawback
Same family, current modelReplace with the successor and convert the programShort stop and wiring almost untouchedAutomatic conversion needs review and testing
Reprogram from scratchNew PLC with a newly written programClean, documented programMore engineering and commissioning hours
In phasesReplace the panel or communications first, then the CPUSpreads cost and riskOld and new equipment coexist for a time

What can be done today without changing anything?

  • Read the program from the PLC and keep two copies, one off site.
  • Take an inventory: model, cards, version and manufacturing status of each unit.
  • Change the backup battery following the manufacturer’s procedure.
  • Buy a spare of the critical parts while they exist.
  • Keep the programming software and cables with the rest of the documentation.

Frequently asked questions

Can the program be recovered from an old PLC?

Almost always, if it is not password-protected and the right software and cable are available. If it is protected, you have to go to the machine builder or reconstruct the operation.

Does the panel have to be replaced as well?

Not always, but old panels are usually discontinued at the same time as the PLC and do not always communicate with the new one. It is assessed case by case.

Is a second-hand spare acceptable?

As a temporary solution, yes. It has no guaranteed life and its price rises as it becomes scarce, so it does not replace a migration plan.

Does replacing the PLC mean recertifying the machine?

Replacing it with an equivalent, without changing functions or safeguards, is not usually regarded as a substantial modification. If safety functions are altered, this must be assessed beforehand.

Contact

Shall we talk about your project?

Tell us what you need and what stage you are at. We will get back to you to arrange a site survey or a proposal.

+34 605 660 658 info@domoticavalencia.es Valencia and metropolitan area