Guides

Retrofit a machine or replace it

A machine with sound mechanics and a control system without spares always raises the same question. This guide gives criteria for deciding without relying on generic figures.

Augusto Martini Chacon · Domotica Valencia · Updated:

In short

Retrofitting a machine means replacing its control system (PLC, operator panel, drives and wiring) while keeping the mechanics. It pays when the mechanics are in good condition, the process will not change and the problem is a lack of spares or diagnostics. Replacement is better when the mechanics are worn, capacity is short or safety requires rebuilding the whole machine.

What is replaced in a retrofit?

  • The PLC and its input and output cards.
  • The operator panel, with clear messages and an alarm log.
  • Motor drives and starters, if discontinued.
  • Deteriorated sensors and wiring.
  • The electrical cabinet, in whole or in part, with new drawings.
  • The mechanics, frame and pneumatic or hydraulic parts are kept.

When does a retrofit pay and when should you replace?

We give no saving percentages: the cost difference between the two options depends on each machine. The comparison is made with two quotes on the table and the cost of each day of downtime.

Criteria for retrofitting or replacing a machine
SituationRetrofitReplace
Condition of the mechanicsGood, with play within toleranceWorn or with repeated mechanical faults
Control sparesDiscontinued or very expensiveNot a factor
Production capacityEnough for the coming yearsInsufficient even when running well
Process and productStay the sameChange significantly
Available stopDays or a few weeksThe new machine can be installed in parallel
SafetyCan be upgraded with limited changesRequires redesigning the machine

What about safety and CE marking?

In Spain, a machine in use must meet the minimum safety provisions for work equipment (Real Decreto 1215/1997). Replacing a PLC with an equivalent one does not, in principle, alter its conformity. It is different if the modification introduces a new hazard or increases a risk: the EU Machinery Regulation 2023/1230, applicable from January 2027, treats whoever carries out a substantial modification as the manufacturer, with the obligations that entails.

That is why it is wise to assess the risks before starting and to record in writing what is changed and what is not. Safety functions are handled with dedicated components, separate from production control.

How is it planned to keep downtime to a minimum?

  • Recover the documentation: drawings, program and signal list. If they do not exist, they are drawn up on site.
  • Agree in writing what the machine must do, including any improvements to be added.
  • Build and test the new cabinet in the workshop, before touching the machine.
  • Make the change in a planned stop, keeping the old cabinet available in case of rollback.
  • Commission with product and with the operators, and hand over drawings, program and backup.

Frequently asked questions

How long is the machine stopped?

It depends on the size of the cabinet and whether it can be prepared in the workshop. The usual approach is to concentrate the change in a planned stop and leave secondary improvements for later.

Can a retrofit be done in phases?

Yes. It is common to replace the panel or the drives first and leave the PLC for a second stop, provided old and new equipment can communicate.

Is the original program lost?

Not necessarily. If it can be read, it serves as a reference. If not, the operation is reconstructed with the operators and by observing the machine.

Can a retrofitted machine be connected to the network?

Yes, and it is often one of the reasons for the change: it lets you see counters, alarms and stop times. The connection uses a separate network with protected access.

Contact

Shall we talk about your project?

Tell us what you need and what stage you are at. We will get back to you to arrange a site survey or a proposal.

+34 605 660 658 info@domoticavalencia.es Valencia and metropolitan area